Why the Jones Act is different
If you are a seaman who has been hurt at work, the Jones Act gives you rights that are dramatically more powerful than the workers’ compensation system that covers most American workers. Most injured seamen do not realize how much is at stake. Most companies do not tell them.
In one screen, what the Jones Act gives you over ordinary workers’ compensation:
- You can sue your employer in federal or state court — workers’ comp prohibits this
- You have the right to a jury trial
- Even slight negligence wins — the “featherweight” causation standard, the most plaintiff-favorable in American tort law
- There is no cap on damages — past and future medical, lost wages, lost earning capacity, pain and suffering, mental anguish, physical impairment
- You can combine three independent federal claims — Jones Act negligence, maintenance and cure, and unseaworthiness — in a single case
Workers’ comp pays a fixed schedule of partial wages. The Jones Act, in the hands of a real maritime trial lawyer, is the most powerful worker-protection framework in the United States.
Before you sign anything: what to do in the first 72 hours
If your injury just happened — or if your loved one is in the hospital tonight — these are the things that matter most right now.
How the Jones Act actually works
The Jones Act is Section 33 of the Merchant Marine Act of 1920, codified today at 46 U.S.C. § 30104. It exists for two enduring reasons: the merchant marine has always been an instrument of national security — a country that cannot supply its forces by sea cannot defend itself — and the seaman has always been the historical “ward of admiralty,” the worker whom courts of admiralty have protected since long before workers’ compensation existed. The Jones Act gave that protection statutory teeth.
A Jones Act case is, in plain English, a federal lawsuit by a seaman against his or her employer for negligence. Three structural features make it powerful.
The featherweight causation standard
To prevail on a Jones Act negligence claim, a seaman need only show that the employer’s negligence played any part — however slight — in producing the injury. This is not rhetorical flourish. It is the actual legal standard, imported from the Federal Employers’ Liability Act (FELA) and applied to maritime cases for nearly a century. The standard is dramatically lower than ordinary tort proximate cause. A jury that believes the employer was even partly responsible can return a full verdict.
The right to a jury
Unlike admiralty cases tried in their pure form, which are tried to a federal judge, a Jones Act case can be tried to a jury. The case can be filed in federal court under 28 U.S.C. § 1333 admiralty jurisdiction or under diversity, or in state court under the savings to suitors clause. The choice of forum — and the right to a jury that comes with it — is one of the most consequential strategic decisions in any Jones Act case. Brian and Vuk make that call at the outset of every case the firm accepts.
Full tort damages, no cap
Past and future lost wages and earning capacity. Past and future medical expenses. Pain and suffering. Mental anguish. Physical impairment and disfigurement. Maintenance and cure are paid separately under the general maritime law. Damages are not capped under the Jones Act.
Who counts as a seaman
Not every maritime worker is a Jones Act seaman. The Supreme Court’s framework comes from Chandris, Inc. v. Latsis (1995): your duties must contribute to the function of the vessel or the accomplishment of its mission, and your connection to the vessel — or to an identifiable group of vessels under common ownership or control — must be substantial in both duration and nature. Courts have used roughly thirty percent of working time aboard as a working benchmark, but the inquiry is fact-intensive. It is a guideline, not an automatic rule.
The seaman category includes:
- Tug, towboat, and barge captains, mates, deckhands, and engineers
- Supply boat, crew boat, and lift boat crews
- Drillship, semisubmersible, and jack-up drilling vessel personnel
- Dredge crews — levermen, mates, mechanics, deckhands (the Supreme Court resolved this in Stewart v. Dutra in 2005)
- Fishing vessel crews
- Roughnecks, roustabouts, drillers, toolpushers, derrickmen, company men, OIMs (Offshore Installation Managers), mud engineers, deck engineers
- Ordinary seaman, able-bodied seaman, tankermen, cooks, galleyhands, and other supporting jobs
It generally excludes longshore workers, who are covered by the LHWCA, shore-based shipyard workers, and workers on fixed offshore platforms, who are covered by OCSLA. The line is fact-specific. If your employer is telling you that you are not a Jones Act seaman, do not accept that without speaking to a maritime lawyer first — worker classification decides which law applies to your injury, and it is the first thing a maritime company’s lawyers will try to characterize in their favor.
Jones Act vs. Longshore vs. workers’ compensation
Sorting the framework correctly is one of the most consequential decisions in any maritime case. The wrong category can cost a worker the value of his or her case.
Jones Act
Federal cause of action. Right to a jury. Featherweight causation. Full tort damages. The most powerful framework available to an injured maritime worker.
LHWCA (Longshore and Harbor Workers’ Compensation Act)
Federal workers’ compensation: scheduled benefits, no jury, limited tort recovery. VB Attorneys does not generally market for LHWCA-only matters. If your case is a Longshore or Harbor Worker claim, we are happy to refer you to an experienced LHWCA lawyer who handles those cases full-time.
State workers’ compensation
Land-based workers who happen to work near the water. State systems vary. Texas, notably, allows employers to opt out of workers’ comp — in which case a negligence claim against the employer is available.
Employers and their insurers regularly try to push injured workers into the lower-recovery category. Do not let them do it without counsel.
How we win Jones Act cases
Serious Jones Act cases resolve because the defense knows we will try them.
That is the entire game. Defense firms and insurance carriers — the small group of national maritime defense firms that handle most Jones Act litigation — keep private lists of which plaintiffs’ lawyers actually try cases at the partner level and which firms hand cases off to junior associates as soon as the marketing brings them in. The number tracks the list.
Brian and Vuk prepare every case for trial from day one. Vessel logs preserved within days. Critical witnesses interviewed before memories drift. Liability experts retained at the outset. Damages models built early. Pretrial motions briefed at federal-practice quality. The substantial majority of our cases resolve before a jury is picked — not because we begged, because the defense did the math.
The cases we take are the cases we are prepared to try.
What the company does after you are hurt
Every one of the points below is something the firm has published on directly. They are the moves injured mariners meet again and again.
How to choose a Jones Act lawyer
In our view, this is the most important question a seriously injured maritime worker has to answer — and the one most often answered badly. The choice of lawyer determines the outcome of the case far more than most clients understand.
The honest framework: in a serious Jones Act case, the only thing that ultimately matters is which lawyer will actually be working on your file when the work matters.
Volume firms vs. trial-first firms
Many of the largest plaintiffs’ firms in the country are marketing organizations first and law firms second. They aggregate thousands of cases through advertising and resolve most of them at the pre-litigation stage through a high-volume, paralegal-driven case-management system. The model works for the routine cases that make up the bulk of any volume practice — there is nothing wrong with the model and nothing wrong with the firms that run it.
Serious Jones Act cases are not the right kind of case for that model. Catastrophic injuries, career-ending injuries, wrongful deaths — these cases are decided in federal court by depositions, motion practice, expert designations, and the credibility of the lawyer who will actually walk into the courtroom. The defense bar in maritime cases is small and specialized. They know exactly which plaintiffs’ firms try cases at the partner level and which firms hand cases off as soon as the marketing brings them in.
Brian has written separately on how to evaluate a lawyer in a serious case, including the questions to ask in the consultation and the things AI-driven lawyer-recommendation tools cannot see: How to Choose a Maritime, Wrongful Death, or Serious Injury Lawyer, and Why AI Can’t Do It for You.
The single most important question, in our view, is the simplest one: which specific lawyer will be working on my file when it matters? At VB Attorneys, the answer is Brian or Vuk. A Board Certified partner runs every file from first call to final resolution.
Jones Act videos
These break down different aspects of the Jones Act and maritime law. Our YouTube channel carries a great deal more.
The Jones Act Explained: What Injured Seamen Are Owed — The Jones Act is the common name for 46 U.S.C. § 30104, a federal statute that provides a statutory remedy for a seaman injured in the course and scope of his employment, against his employer and possibly others. Brian explains the Jones Act and its intricacies.
How to Hire a Maritime Lawyer: What to Ask Before You Sign — When you’ve been hurt in an offshore or maritime accident, time is not on your side. More than likely you’re putting your energy into recovering and trying to pay your bills, and you may not be sure where to turn or who to trust.
How To Pay Your Bills After a Maritime Accident — Maritime companies use financial pressure against you — to force you to quit and give up, or to come back to work before you’re ready. It is a tactic designed specifically to protect their money.
Protect yourself from getting blackballed — Brian Beckcom explains the concept of being “blackballed” or “blacklisted” in the marine industry, and how to assert your legal rights after a maritime injury without that fear.
How long will you get Maintenance Payments after a Maritime Injury? — After a maritime injury your offshore company must pay maintenance until you reach Maximum Medical Improvement. Company doctors tend to reach MMI sooner than you do — which is when the payments stop.
Books and resources on the Jones Act
The Jones Act is a complicated piece of legislation designed to protect seamen. Below are resources to educate yourself on all aspects of it. If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to reach out to us.
Blackballed
If you are reading this book, you have the same fear that many have in the maritime industry. You are probably afraid that you will get fired and blackballed in the industry if you hire an attorney or bring a legal claim. You may believe that you will be put on a “blacklist” or a “Do Not Hire” list. You are afraid for your future. You are afraid that you will never be able to find work in the maritime industry again. Brian answers all of your questions in this book.
Insider’s Guide to Winning Your Maritime Injury Case
The purpose of this book is to level the playing field between the offshore companies and the insurance companies. We want you to have as much information as possible so you can handle your case and make decisions intelligently. It will also arm you with information so you can make decisions about what to do about your case and your legal rights, without being misled, misinformed, or mistreated.
Protecting Your Future
All too often, the employer (or its insurance company) treats the injured worker badly. The company makes the injured worker visit only company doctors. Or the company forces the injured worker back to work before he is ready. Sometimes, the company will even fire the injured worker after he is hurt. In these types of situations, it really is a no-brainer for the injured maritime worker to seek immediate legal help from an experienced maritime attorney. In this book, Brian lays out the steps to win your maritime injury case.
How to Hire the Best Attorney For Your Maritime Injury Case
When you’ve been hurt in an offshore or maritime accident, time is not on your side. This book explains what to look for in a maritime lawyer, what questions to ask, and how to tell a firm that tries these cases from a firm that refers them out.