Case Results · Maritime Injury Law

A swinging crane weight injured a deckhand working for Skanska

A deckhand was helping bring a barge toward a pier when a crane’s headache ball swung into his left foot. Vuk Vujasinovic served as lead counsel, with Job Tennant as trial counsel. Skanska stipulated to Jones Act negligence and vessel unseaworthiness causing the injuries. The jury determined damages on those claims and separately decided maintenance-and-cure questions, returning a total verdict of $2,218,000.

Verdict$2,218,000
TrialAugust 7–10, 2023
CourtState court, Escambia County, Florida
Lead counselVuk Vujasinovic
Trial counselJob Tennant
Case typeJones Act · Maritime

A crane movement at the loadout pier

On June 19, 2020, the deckhand was working aboard a barge at the Three Mile Bridge project’s precast loadout area. Skanska’s safety report places the incident at approximately 5:30 p.m. and describes his task immediately before the injury as mooring the barge.

The report describes a crane being brought from the bridge to the loadout area. The crane operator lowered the boom to pass beneath the bridge. As the tugboat captain approached the pier, the deckhand gave the captain distances.

The deckhand stood between a power pack and the crane’s headache ball, which was resting on the barge deck. When the operator raised the boom as the barge approached the pier, the ball swung toward the deckhand and struck his left foot, according to Skanska’s report.

What Skanska stipulated and what the jury decided

The case went to trial in Escambia County, Florida, on August 7–10, 2023. Vuk and Job represented the injured deckhand.

Skanska stipulated that it was liable for Jones Act negligence and that the vessel F. DAWSON was unseaworthy, with both causing the deckhand’s injuries. The jury therefore determined damages on those claims. It also answered separate questions about maintenance and cure, including whether Skanska had failed to pay and whether that failure had a reasonable defense.

Challenging the defense expert’s opinions

Before trial, Vuk Vujasinovic challenged the opinions offered by Skanska’s retained physical therapist. His motion asked the court to limit testimony to properly disclosed, supported opinions within the expert’s qualifications. On August 3, 2023, the court limited the therapist’s trial testimony to his physical examination and excluded his proposed “validity assessment” and speculative opinion about the cause of the deckhand’s smaller left calf. The ruling narrowed the opinions this defense expert could present at trial.

The $2,218,000 verdict

The jury’s award consisted of six nonzero components:

  1. Past general damages: $300,000.
  2. Future general damages: $1,000,000.
  3. Future medical expenses: $250,000.
  4. Past lost earnings: $68,000.
  5. Future loss of earning capacity: $500,000.
  6. Aggravation of the condition caused by the unreasonable failure to pay maintenance and cure: $100,000.

The maintenance-and-cure finding

The jury found that Skanska failed to pay maintenance and cure without a reasonable defense. It awarded $100,000 to compensate for aggravation of the deckhand’s condition caused by that failure. That amount was compensatory damages, not punitive damages or an award of unpaid benefit amounts.

The jury did not find the failure willful and arbitrary. The final judgment awarded no punitive damages and denied attorney’s fees for pursuing the maintenance-and-cure claim.

Judgment entered and later satisfied

The court entered final judgment on September 15, 2023, reflecting $2,218,000 in general and special damages. On July 31, 2024, the court entered an order recognizing that judgment as fully satisfied.

What the evidence showed

  1. Skanska’s safety report describes a crane’s headache ball swinging into the deckhand’s left foot while the barge approached a loadout pier.
  2. Skanska stipulated to Jones Act negligence and vessel unseaworthiness causing the injuries; the jury decided damages and separate maintenance-and-cure questions.
  3. The six nonzero verdict components total $2,218,000. The July 31, 2024 court order recognizes the judgment as fully satisfied.

Questions about the deckhand verdict

Skanska’s safety report describes a crane’s headache ball swinging into the deckhand’s left foot as the barge approached a precast loadout pier. He had been giving distances to the tugboat captain.
Skanska stipulated to Jones Act negligence and vessel unseaworthiness causing the deckhand’s injuries. The jury determined damages on those claims and separately decided maintenance-and-cure questions.
No. The jury awarded $100,000 for aggravation caused by Skanska’s unreasonable failure to pay maintenance and cure, but did not find that failure willful and arbitrary. The final judgment awarded no punitive damages.

Every case is different. Prior results depend on the facts of the individual case and do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Tell us what happened

If something like this happened to you or someone in your family, that is exactly the conversation to have. The first one is free, and you will get a straight answer.

Call our office directly for a free and confidential case review.

(877) 724-7800

No fees unless we win your case

If this form is unavailable, please call (877) 724-7800.

No fees unless we win. Confidential evaluation.