The Incident: Tripping Pipe in the Gulf of Mexico
On September 30, 2000, a roughneck employed by R & B Falcon Drilling USA, Inc. was engaged in pipe-tripping operations aboard a jack-up rig in the Gulf of Mexico. Without warning, the main brake system on the pipe-lift elevator experienced total structural failure while holding heavy drill pipe loads.
The unsecured elevator assembly plummeted onto the rig floor, crushing the worker’s foot, dragging him across the deck, and slamming him violently into the central drawworks hoisting apparatus.
Liability & Discovery: Unsecured Pins and Critical Contractor Negligence
One month before the catastrophic failure, Southern Technology & Services Inc., an oilfield contractor based in Houma, Louisiana, was hired to repair and overhaul the rig’s drawworks. Forensic discovery demonstrated that during reassembly of the braking hardware, contractor personnel failed to fasten and secure the critical retaining pins required to maintain structural integrity under load.
Lead counsel Brian Beckcom filed federal maritime claims against employer R & B Falcon Drilling USA, Inc. under the Jones Act for employer negligence and general maritime law for unseaworthiness of the vessel. Concurrent third-party maritime negligence claims were asserted against Southern Technology & Services Inc. for defective maintenance and improper mechanical overhaul.
Corporate Cross-Claims and Comparative Fault Defenses
Throughout depositions, both corporate entities sought to evade responsibility. Southern Technology’s supervisor admitted under oath that he was not physically present on the rig during the brake overhaul, alleging that R & B Falcon’s crew performed the installation. Conversely, R & B Falcon produced internal rig records showing the contractor’s personnel performed the defective service work.
Faced with overwhelming physical proof of mechanical negligence, the defense pivoted to comparative fault tactics. Defendants argued the roughneck was contributorily negligent for failing to dodge the falling elevator, pointing out that co-workers avoided injury and alleging that ill-fitting work boots restricted his mobility on the rig deck.
VB Attorneys methodically dismantled these defenses, establishing that no worker could anticipate an instantaneous brake collapse caused by missing safety fasteners on essential rig machinery.
Medical Realities: Reflex Sympathetic Dystrophy (RSD) and Lumbar Surgery
The crush impact inflicted severe trauma to the worker’s foot and severe rotational forces across his spinal column. Medical evaluations confirmed severe crush injury to the hallux (big toe) leading to Reflex Sympathetic Dystrophy (RSD/CRPS)—a painful, debilitating neurological condition. The lumbar trauma caused herniations requiring a surgical discectomy.
The defense retained two independent medical examiners (IMEs) who aggressively disputed the RSD diagnosis, contested the origin of the spinal injuries, and claimed the worker was fully capable of returning to heavy labor. Objective diagnostic imaging and treating specialist testimony discredited the defense experts.
Settlement and Payment
The case proceeded in the 172nd District Court of Jefferson County, Texas, and resolved in May 2003. A total of $950,000 was paid in Settlement.
What the evidence showed
- The repair. The pins for the braking unit were never secured when the brakes were reworked a month earlier.
- The finger-pointing. Each company said the other did the brake work.
- The blame on the worker. Defense arguments claiming the worker moved too slowly and that ill-fitting boots impaired his mobility.
- The medicine. Reflex sympathetic dystrophy and lower back surgery, disputed by two defense doctors.
Settlement
The case resolved in May 2003.
More from the record
Frequently Asked Questions
Every case is different. Prior results depend on the facts of the individual case and do not guarantee a similar outcome.