Case Results · Maritime Injury Law

A failed D-ring sent a crane hook into Gabriel’s head

The crew lowered a hatch cover into place aboard the SS Antares when a D-ring broke free. The hook and lifting gear swung toward Gabriel D., striking his head. He lost consciousness. The injuries would require neck surgery and leave him struggling with pain, memory and concentration. Case counsel: Brian Beckcom.

Recovery$3.5 Million Settlement

Case at a glance

  1. Recovery: $3.5 Million Settlement
  2. Practice: Maritime Injury Law
  3. Representation: Brian Beckcom, Brendan Fradkin and VB Attorneys.

A heavy lift and a failed connection

Gabriel worked aboard the SS Antares, a United States-owned vessel managed by TOTE Maritime. The crew handled a hatch cover with a crane. During the operation, a D-ring used as a connection point failed.

The hook and attached lifting gear struck Gabriel in the head. He suffered severe head and neck injuries, including a cervical fracture. His treatment included a C1–C2 fusion, surgery joining two vertebrae near the top of his neck.

Cargo-hatch covers and crane on the deck of the SS Antares.
The deck, cargo-hatch covers and crane aboard the SS Antares.

The injury continued after the surgery

The operation addressed part of the physical damage. It did not end the case’s medical questions. Gabriel continued to report headaches and neck pain, and his legal team documented problems with memory, concentration and other cognitive functions.

In preparing his claim, Brian Beckcom and VB Attorneys addressed both the physical injuries and the consequences of the head injury. The damages presentation included future medical care, lost income and the effect on Gabriel’s ability to work and manage everyday tasks.

Brian’s investigation focused on the D-ring

Brian Beckcom and Brendan Fradkin represented Gabriel in the case against the United States in federal court in Maryland.

The investigation went beyond the fact that a piece of equipment had broken. The team examined the preparation for the lift, the inspection and maintenance of the D-ring, and the testimony of people who witnessed the incident or helped afterward.

Brian argued that testimony from the vessel manager’s corporate representative supported three failures: no regular testing for corrosion or condition, no pull testing before the lift, and no maintenance that ensured the D-ring was fit for use.

Damaged mounting plate with pieces marked PF1 and PF2.
A later close view of the mounting plate, with damaged pieces marked PF1 and PF2.

Preparing the maritime claims for a decision

The case included claims involving Jones Act negligence, the vessel’s condition and maintenance and cure. The fact that the vessel belonged to the United States also shaped the litigation.

After discovery, the team prepared to seek a pretrial ruling on negligence and unseaworthiness. The United States had not agreed to admit those claims. The team prepared to present both the equipment-failure evidence and the long-term consequences of Gabriel’s injuries.

A $3.5 million settlement

The case resolved through a $3.5 million settlement with the United States. The settlement resolved Gabriel’s maritime injury case in 2024.

The recovery addressed a case involving major neck surgery and continuing cognitive injuries.

Questions about the case

A D-ring failed during a crane operation involving a hatch cover. The hook and attached lifting gear struck Gabriel in the head, causing severe head and neck injuries.
The team investigated the D-ring’s condition, inspection and maintenance, preparation for the lift, and witness testimony. Brian argued that the evidence supported negligence and unseaworthiness claims.
Brian Beckcom and Brendan Fradkin of VB Attorneys represented Gabriel in the federal case against the United States.

Related legal help

Learn about maritime injury claims and Jones Act cases, or read another case involving a seaman’s head injury during vessel work.

For a free consultation about a maritime injury, call 877-724-7800.

Every case is different. Prior results depend on the facts of the individual case and do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Tell us what happened

If something like this happened to you or someone in your family, that is exactly the conversation to have. The first one is free, and you will get a straight answer.

Call our office directly for a free and confidential case review.

(877) 724-7800

No fees unless we win your case

If this form is unavailable, please call (877) 724-7800.

No fees unless we win. Confidential evaluation.