Truck Accidents · Houston, Texas

Freight Broker Liability & Negligent Carrier Selection

A freight broker chooses the carrier that will move a load. When unsafe carrier selection contributes to a crash, the broker’s decisions deserve investigation. In Montgomery, the Supreme Court allowed a negligent-hiring claim to proceed under the FAAAA’s motor-vehicle safety exception.

What Is a Freight Broker, and Why Does It Matter to Your Case?

Most loads are not arranged by the trucking company directly. A broker matches the shipper’s freight to a carrier, and is paid to choose a safe one. When the broker instead chooses the cheapest carrier on the board, ignoring a poor federal safety record, the broker helped put an unsafe truck on the road. Brokers are also frequently the better-insured, more solvent defendant, which is why identifying one early can change the value of the entire case.

What Montgomery Decided About Broker Claims

On May 14, 2026, a unanimous U.S. Supreme Court held in Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II, LLC that the FAAAA’s motor-vehicle safety exception saved Montgomery’s negligent-hiring claim against C.H. Robinson from federal preemption. The Court assumed, without deciding, that the claim would otherwise fall within the Act’s preemption provision. It reversed and remanded for further proceedings; it did not decide whether the broker was negligent.

That decision opens the way to examine the broker’s carrier-screening decisions and the safety information available when it selected the carrier. Building the claim means connecting that evidence to the duty of care, the crash and the resulting harm under the governing law.

How We Prove a Broker Chose a Dangerous Carrier

We go straight to the documents: broker load logs, carrier-screening records, the FMCSA Safety Measurement System data the broker had access to, and the internal dispatch emails that show what it knew. Those records help answer a central question: did the broker ignore evidence that the carrier was unsafe when it handed over the load?

Most cases settle, and the number they settle at depends on whether the other side believes your case is ready for a courtroom. Ours always are; our Truck Accidents page shows exactly how we prepare one.

Quick Answers

Freight broker liability questions, answered.

Potentially. In Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II, LLC, the Supreme Court held that the FAAAA’s motor-vehicle safety exception saved the negligent-hiring claim before it. A successful claim still depends on the governing law and evidence about the carrier’s selection and the crash.
Choosing a motor carrier the broker knew or should have known was unsafe, typically based on its FMCSA safety record, and putting its truck on the road anyway.
The bills of lading, dispatch records, and load documents reveal the chain. We subpoena them early, before they can go missing.
Because many carriers run on minimum coverage that a catastrophic injury exhausts quickly. The broker is often the better-insured, more solvent defendant, and adding one can change the value of the entire case.
Broker load logs, carrier-screening files, FMCSA Safety Measurement System data, and internal dispatch emails. Together they answer one question: what did the broker know when it handed over the load?

Tell us what happened

If a truck crash has upended your life, the broker and the carrier are already lawyering up. The first conversation is free, and you will get a straight answer about whether we can help.

Call our office directly for a free and confidential case review.

(877) 724-7800

No fees unless we win your case

If this form is unavailable, please call (877) 724-7800.

No fees unless we win. Confidential evaluation.