From the Firm

Who Investigates a Maritime Disaster?

When a vessel goes down, four investigations begin. Only one of them works for the crew.

Within two days of the tanker Atlantic Asphalt striking the riverboat American Heritage in New Orleans, the National Transportation Safety Board had investigators on the case, the Coast Guard was holding the tanker at a dock in Gretna, the companies’ own people were at work, and four crew members had filed suit and asked in writing for a seat at the vessel inspection. Four investigations of one collision, each one built for a different reason. If you work on the water, you should know what each of them is for, because only one of them is for you.

The safety investigation

The National Transportation Safety Board answers one question: why did this happen. Its investigators pull the voyage data recorder, walk the vessel, and interview the crew. A preliminary report usually comes within weeks, and the full report can take a year or more. The board does real work and its findings change safety rules, but it cannot award anyone a dollar and it cannot hold anyone accountable. Its report is written for safety, not for your case, and parts of it cannot even be used in court.

The enforcement investigation

The Coast Guard runs its own marine casualty investigation, and this one has teeth. It can test crews for drugs and alcohol, act against officers’ licenses, refer violations for penalties, and keep a vessel right where it is. That is why the Atlantic Asphalt sits at a dock in Gretna instead of sailing on to its next port.

Brian Beckcom in a hard hat during a cargo-ship inspection, with containers and cranes behind him
Brian Beckcom aboard a cargo ship during a vessel inspection. The inspection is critically important to every case, and the injured seaman and his lawyer must participate in any inspections.

The company’s investigation

The fastest investigation belongs to the companies. Within hours of a casualty, their adjusters, marine surveyors, and defense lawyers are at work, sometimes before the injured crew have left the dock. This investigation exists to measure the company’s exposure and shrink it. The statement a deckhand gives in those first shaken days has a way of showing up years later, read back to him word by word in a deposition. The people taking it are polite, professional, and not on his side.

The investigation that works for the injured

The fourth investigation is the one the injured worker’s own lawyers run, and it is the only one whose job is his recovery. It starts with preservation demands: the recorder data, the maintenance and repair records, the work orders, the crew list before everyone scatters to new vessels. It continues at the inspection and in the interviews. In New Orleans, the injured crew’s lawyers asked in writing to take part in the ship inspection and the crew interviews. That seat at the table is not given. It is claimed, and the earlier it is claimed, the more there is left to find.

If it happens on your vessel

Write down what you saw while it is fresh, with names. Keep your own copies of anything you sign. Photograph what you safely can. See a doctor and report every symptom, not just the worst one. And before you give the company’s investigators a recorded statement, talk to a maritime injury lawyer whose only client is you. The companies start protecting themselves within hours. You are allowed to do the same.

Sources: reporting on the New Orleans collision by the Associated Press and gCaptain, November 13 through 17, 2026.

Tell us what happened

Reading about a case is not the same as having one looked at. If something happened to you or someone in your family, the first conversation is free.

Call our office directly for a free and confidential case review.

(877) 724-7800

No fees unless we win your case

If this form is unavailable, please call (877) 724-7800.

No fees unless we win. Confidential evaluation.