Case Results · Transportation Accidents

Momentum Motor Cars Crash: Erika’s $305,000 Total Settlement

Erika M. fractured her left elbow when a Momentum Motor Cars employee broadsided her car while driving a company-owned Jaguar. Brian Beckcom challenged the dealership’s decision to entrust him with the vehicle despite his driving history and an earlier company-car crash. When the dealership’s insurer became insolvent, Brian continued the case through a second mediation. The total settlement reached $305,000.

Recovery$305,000 Total Settlement

Case at a glance

  1. Result: $305,000 Total Settlement
  2. Practice: Transportation Accidents

Attorney: Brian Beckcom

A company Jaguar struck Erika’s car

On December 1, 1999, a Momentum Motor Cars employee missed a turn and broadsided Erika M.’s Geo Prism. He was driving a Jaguar that the Houston dealership owned while returning home from dinner with a friend in the car.

Erika fractured her left elbow in multiple places. A surgeon repaired the elbow and placed hardware. She later underwent two more operations to remove some of that hardware. Her past medical expenses totaled approximately $69,000.

Momentum supplied a company car despite an earlier crash

The driver’s insurer tendered its $20,000 policy limits early in the litigation. Brian also pursued Momentum on Erika’s behalf, primarily through a negligent-entrustment claim. That claim focused on the dealership’s decision to give its vehicle to this driver.

Through discovery, Brian established that the employee had an unfavorable driving record when Momentum hired him. That discovery also revealed that Momentum had reprimanded him after an earlier crash in a company vehicle.

Brian argued that Momentum knew or should have known that the employee was a reckless driver and should not have entrusted the Jaguar to him. Brian also asserted vicarious liability, while the negligent-entrustment claim addressed the dealership’s own conduct.

The insurer’s insolvency interrupted settlement efforts

Momentum’s insurer, Reliance Insurance Company, offered $150,000 at the first mediation and later increased the offer to $200,000. Erika did not accept. Reliance withdrew its offers as its financial problems grew and subsequently became insolvent.

The Texas State Guaranty Fund assumed the defense of the case and retained new defense counsel. A second mediation followed in October 2002.

A $305,000 total settlement

The second mediation resolved the claim against Momentum for $285,000 through the Guaranty Fund. Together with the driver’s insurer’s $20,000 contribution, the total settlement amounted to $305,000.

Tell Us What Happened

Read about transportation accident claims. To discuss an injury claim with Brian, call (877) 724-7800 or Tell Us What Happened.

Case questions

Her negligent-entrustment claim challenged Momentum’s decision to provide a company vehicle to an employee with an unfavorable driving record and an earlier company-car crash.
The total settlement amounted to $305,000: $285,000 through the Guaranty Fund and $20,000 from the driver’s insurer.

Every case is different. Prior results depend on the facts of the individual case and do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Tell us what happened

If something like this happened to you or someone in your family, that is exactly the conversation to have. The first one is free, and you will get a straight answer.

Call our office directly for a free and confidential case review.

(877) 724-7800

No fees unless we win your case

If this form is unavailable, please call (877) 724-7800.

No fees unless we win. Confidential evaluation.