Case at a glance
- Recovery: Confidential Settlement
- Injury: Right knee injury; ACL reconstruction
- Practice: Maritime Injury Law
- Attorneys: Vuk Vujasinovic
A knee injury inside a fish-processing tank
Justin was working aboard a fishing vessel in the Bering Sea. His duties included cleaning a tank used in the fish-processing operation. While he was inside the tank, the vessel lurched and he injured his right knee.
The working area became an important part of the case. The metal tank sloped downward, had limited overhead clearance near one end and lacked handholds. Cleaning it required a worker to enter a confined space while the vessel itself was moving.
The weather was not a minor detail. The vessel’s weather log recorded rough seas. The team retained a weather specialist to examine the forecasts issued before the incident and compare them with available observations.
Limited duty did not mean the knee could rest
After the first injury, Justin received instructions for rest, ice, compression and elevation, along with nonprescription pain medication. But he continued performing limited duties aboard the vessel while his knee remained painful.
He later described a second incident while offloading boxes of fish in the cargo hold. The conveyor repeatedly jammed. A heavy box pressed against him, and as he tried to brace himself with an already painful leg, he felt his knee give way.
The medical information reviewed in the case documented continuing difficulty bearing weight and moving around the vessel. A factory manager expressed concern about both the condition of Justin’s knee and his ability to work safely without further injury. He was eventually sent ashore for additional care.
Justin later underwent ACL reconstruction. During a medical examination, he described months of physical therapy and continuing knee symptoms after the operation.
Inspecting the tank and reconstructing the working conditions
The VB Attorneys team engaged a marine safety expert who visited the vessel, photographed the work areas and measured the tank. He reviewed Justin’s deposition, incident reports, the vessel’s medical log and the records of care provided aboard the ship.
The inspection gave the team concrete details to evaluate: smooth metal surfaces, a sloped tank floor, low overhead clearance and no handholds. The expert questioned whether a worker should have been inside that tank in rough seas and identified cleaning from outside the tank with a long-handled tool as an alternative.
The team also examined what happened after the initial injury. Its marine expert questioned whether Justin could receive the prescribed rest while continuing even limited work aboard a moving vessel. He separately examined the conveyor jams and the physical effort required to clear them.
The team used this analysis to connect the physical setting with the sequence of events: the first knee injury, continuing work despite pain, and the later incident in the cargo hold.
Looking beyond a single moment of injury
The case involved more than the movement of a ship. The team investigated the task Justin was performing, the conditions in which he was expected to perform it, and the response when his knee did not improve.
The weather specialist reviewed National Weather Service forecasts and observations alongside the vessel’s weather log. That work allowed the team to evaluate what conditions had been forecast before the injury, rather than relying only on later recollections of rough seas.
Vuk worked through settlement discussions and a mediator’s proposal. The case resolved through a confidential settlement, concluding Justin’s maritime injury claims.
Questions about the case
Related legal help
Learn about maritime injury claims or read about another deckhand injury case.
To speak with VB Attorneys about an injury aboard a vessel, call 877-724-7800 for a free consultation.
Every case is different. Prior results depend on the facts of the individual case and do not guarantee a similar outcome.