Case at a glance
- Recovery: Confidential Settlement
- Injury: Knee injury and aggravation claims
- Practice: Maritime Injury Law
- Attorneys: Brian Beckcom and Brendan Fradkin
An offshore worker’s account needed to be heard
Gerald worked as an able seaman aboard a drillship. His work took him away from home for weeks at a time, living and sleeping aboard the vessel during his offshore rotation.
He was cleaning aboard the drillship when the incident occurred. After he was taken to a hospital, an adjuster met with him and recorded his account. Gerald said he thought he had tripped or slipped, hit his head and then suffered a seizure.
The sequence of events was disputed. The company’s initial classification treated the episode as nonwork-related, while Gerald maintained that a fall had come first. That difference mattered to understanding what happened and how his injury claims should be evaluated.
Gerald also claimed a knee injury from the incident and a later aggravation while using stairs aboard the vessel. His knee problems persisted well beyond his initial hospital visit.
The captain had not been given Gerald’s account
Brendan questioned the captain about the company’s incident-reporting procedures and the decision to classify the event as nonwork-related. The examination focused on the information the captain had actually received, not just the classification written in the report.
The captain testified that no one had told him Gerald reported believing he fell before the seizure. He said that information would have prompted additional investigation, either by him or with assistance from the vessel’s safety personnel.
He identified witness statements as part of the work he would have undertaken. He also agreed that collecting statements promptly was important, before people forgot what happened.
The testimony exposed a gap between Gerald’s early account and the information available to the captain. It gave Brian and Brendan a concrete basis to challenge whether the initial classification reflected a complete investigation.
Following the evidence beyond the initial report
Brian separately questioned the adjuster who had spoken with Gerald after the hospital visit. That testimony confirmed that Gerald had reported thinking he slipped or tripped and hit his head before the seizure.
Brian and Brendan also examined how the company handled Gerald’s maritime medical and living-expense benefits. The adjuster testified that payments began promptly after the incident. Those records and the early statement became part of the evidence they developed alongside the captain’s testimony.
Meanwhile, Gerald continued seeking care for his right knee. His orthopedic specialist documented pain with walking and stairs, along with Gerald’s report that the knee sometimes felt as though it would give out.
A cortisone injection provided relief for a few months, but the pain returned. His doctor repeated the injection and discussed further treatment options. The records also documented arthritis, making it important to distinguish the underlying knee condition from the injury and aggravation Gerald claimed.
Overturning a dismissal that threatened to end the case
Gerald’s claim against Noble Drilling Services, Inc. faced a setback that threatened to end it before trial. After Brian and Brendan sought to dismiss the Fort Bend County action without prejudice, the trial court instead entered a dismissal with prejudice, barring him from refiling those claims. Brian Beckcom, Brendan Fradkin and the team worked with appellate counsel Matthew Kita to challenge that ruling. The Fourteenth Court of Appeals reversed it and restored Gerald’s right to pursue the claims.
Brian and Brendan had already filed a separate federal action while the appeal was pending. After the appellate victory, the federal court lifted its stay, and the litigation continued toward a confidential settlement.
A confidential settlement of the maritime injury claims
Brian, Brendan and the VB Attorneys team continued pursuing Gerald’s claims, examining the company’s response to the incident and the medical evidence concerning his ongoing knee problems. The case resolved through a confidential settlement.
The investigation went beyond accepting an initial label. By comparing Gerald’s early statement with the captain’s testimony and the company’s handling of the claim, Brian and Brendan brought the missing information into the case and pursued a resolution for their client.
Questions about the case
Related legal help
Learn about maritime injury claims or read about another deckhand injury case.
To speak with VB Attorneys about an injury aboard a vessel, call 877-724-7800 for a free consultation.
Every case is different. Prior results depend on the facts of the individual case and do not guarantee a similar outcome.