Case Results · Truck Accidents

Settlement for a Truck Driver After a Disputed Axle-Failure Rollover

RecoveryConfidential Settlement

David K. hauled crude oil in an 18-wheeler. When his loaded trailer pulled to the right, he looked in the mirror and saw an axle hanging beneath it. The truck rolled, breaking bones in his neck, back, ribs and collarbone. His employer blamed his driving. Brian Beckcom and VB Attorneys represented David in a case that involved the axle’s repair history, metal testing and an arbitration agreement he had signed in the hospital. The case ultimately settled at mediation.

Damaged truck with a covered cab and axle assembly resting across its rear chassis at a storage yard.
The damaged truck and recovered equipment at a storage yard after the crash.

Case at a glance

  1. Practice: Truck Accidents
  2. Representation: Brian Beckcom and VB Attorneys.

A loaded trailer pulled off course

David drove hazardous-material loads for a commercial trucking company. His work required him to manage a tractor and trailer carrying crude oil, including travel on dirt roads. On the morning of the crash, he felt the loaded trailer pulling to the right and struggled to keep it on the road.

David later described a brief view in his passenger-side mirror: an axle hung beneath the trailer. He could not regain control. The truck and trailer rolled over.

The rollover fractured his neck, back, ribs and collarbone. He also suffered bruising, hematomas and scars. Hospital care came first. While he recovered on a morphine drip, a second problem developed around the paperwork his employer brought to his room.

The axle had a repair history

The axle did not enter the case as an unexplained piece of broken metal. Before the rollover, the trailer had experienced repeated axle problems. Brian’s investigation traced at least five occasions when repair work included welding.

Mechanics had recommended replacement during one of the later repairs. The request went to the trucking company’s maintenance director, who authorized another welding repair instead. The repair included plating and welding the axle before the company returned the trailer to service.

The repair history raised a central question: did the axle break before the rollover, or did the rollover break it? David said the axle failed before the truck overturned. The company maintained that his driving caused the crash.

The company blamed the driver

The responding officer cited David for failing to take appropriate corrective action and driving at an unsafe speed. The citation described a speed of 61 miles per hour in a 60-mile-per-hour zone. Those citations added another obstacle to the claim.

David also stood as the only witness who could describe what he saw and felt inside the truck. The company disputed his explanation. Brian therefore needed physical evidence that could help determine the sequence: whether an axle failure caused the rollover or the rollover broke the axle.

Metal testing changed the analysis

Broken steel support bracket beside a wheel in an axle-inspection photograph.
A broken support bracket and wheel photographed during the later axle inspection.

Metallurgical testing examined the metal and its failure characteristics. The initial results did not support a straightforward claim that the weld had progressively failed after the repair. Brian continued working with his experts rather than treating the repair history as the entire answer.

The experts developed a different explanation: a force before the rollover, such as a pothole or substantial bump, snapped the axle. David’s case rested on the argument that the physical evidence supported a pre-crash break. The trucking company continued to deny a weld failure and blamed David for losing control.

The competing explanations made expert work central to the case. Brian had to address the testing results as they actually stood, explain his causation theory and prepare for an arbitrator to weigh that theory against the company’s account.

David prepared for a deposition that would address the trailer’s movement, what he saw in the mirror and the circumstances of the wreck. His account and the physical evidence had to explain the same sequence of events.

Hospital paperwork changed where the case would proceed

While David recovered in the hospital, a company representative brought documents concerning his benefits. David and his wife later challenged the circumstances of the signing. Their account described a medicated patient who did not understand that the documents included an arbitration agreement.

David filed suit and opposed the company’s request to compel arbitration. The trial court refused to enforce the agreement. The company appealed, and the appellate court reversed that decision because David had continued accepting benefits under the plan after learning about the arbitration issue.

The appellate ruling moved the dispute toward arbitration. It did not decide what caused the axle to break or resolve David’s injury claim. The dispute continued in that changed setting, with the maintenance evidence, testing and David’s testimony still at issue.

The case settled at mediation

Portrait of David K., VB Attorneys’ truck-driver client
David K., the truck driver VB Attorneys represented after the rollover.

The parties reached a settlement at mediation. David gained a resolution after a case that had involved serious injuries, disputed responsibility, an appeal and competing expert explanations.

David later spoke appreciatively about the firm’s help finding doctors and getting answers about his injuries. Those practical concerns had accompanied the legal dispute from the beginning. He needed care and a way forward while his former employer challenged his account of the rollover.

David K., in his own words.

David K. describes the aftermath of his 18-wheeler crash, finding medical help and his experience with VB Attorneys. Published September 1, 2016 · 2 minutes 14 seconds. Watch David K.’s testimonial on YouTube.

Transcript (lightly edited for readability)

Name abbreviated

Hi, my name’s [David K.]. I was injured in that 18-wheeler accident.

When the accident happened, at first I didn’t think I was injured until I got out of that truck and noticed that I was injured and I was trying to get some help.

Probably about five minutes after it happened, I noticed a white pickup with their headlights coming down, and I just laid down. The pain started hurting. I mean, the pain hit, and after that I don’t remember much. I know that the other driver had to call for help.

Companies, they’re all out just for their bottom line. They don’t care about other drivers or employees. They just care about themselves and about their revenue.

Several months after the accident, when I got my memory back and everything from the wreck, and talking to my family and everything, they told me that I needed to get an attorney to help get my medical and stuff to get going so that I could see doctors and stuff.

I was looking through the internet. And for some reason, you guys’ name popped up. And for some reason I was attracted to this law firm. So, God was telling me this law firm to hire. That’s how I came across this law firm.

You guys really helped me out, finding a doctor and actually getting the answers that I’ve been requesting about myself and the injuries I sustained in that accident. And you guys really helped me out with it quite a bit.

I say, thank you very much. You’ve been really good help. And you’ve been great through all this process. And I couldn’t ask for a better team than you guys.

Questions about David’s case

David said the axle failed before the truck rolled. The trucking company blamed his driving. Repair records and metallurgical testing became central to determining the sequence of events.
The company sought to enforce an agreement David signed in the hospital. The trial court declined to enforce it, but the appellate court reversed after considering David’s continued acceptance of benefits under the plan.
The parties reached a settlement at mediation after the lawsuit, appeal and competing expert analyses.
Brian Beckcom and VB Attorneys represented David in his truck rollover case.

Discuss an injury with VB Attorneys

If you or someone in your family suffered injuries in a truck crash, tell us what happened. Contact Brian Beckcom and VB Attorneys to discuss your case.

Explore our truck accidents practice.

Brian Beckcom

Every case is different. Prior results depend on the facts of the individual case and do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Tell us what happened

If something like this happened to you or someone in your family, that is exactly the conversation to have. The first one is free, and you will get a straight answer.

Call our office directly for a free and confidential case review.

(877) 724-7800

No fees unless we win your case

If this form is unavailable, please call (877) 724-7800.

No fees unless we win. Confidential evaluation.