When the Mexican Navy’s tall ship Cuauhtémoc lost power and crashed into the Brooklyn Bridge on May 17, 2025, the headlines focused on the dramatic scene: snapped masts, injuries, and the tragic deaths of two young cadets. But behind the scenes, another story may soon unfold, one involving a controversial 19th-century law that could determine how much (or how little) the victims and their families are compensated.
We’re talking about the Limitation of Liability Act of 1851, a law that allows shipowners to limit their liability for injuries, deaths, and property damage to the post-accident value of the vessel and its remaining cargo. In this case, that could be shockingly low, given that the Cuauhtémoc suffered major damage in the crash. If the ship’s owners or associated entities invoke the Limitation Act, they may attempt to shield themselves from the full financial consequences of this disaster.
As we’ve written before, this law is a relic, originally designed to protect American shipping interests in an era before modern insurance and global commerce. Today, it’s often used as a legal loophole by corporations and governments trying to avoid paying fair compensation to injured workers and grieving families. It prioritizes profit over people and fails to reflect the realities of modern maritime operations.
In a tragedy like this, where two cadets lost their lives and dozens more were injured, attempting to limit liability under such an archaic statute is not only unjust, it’s insulting. Victims deserve full accountability, not legal maneuvers designed to minimize payouts.
At VB Attorneys, we’ve spent years fighting for maritime workers and families caught in these exact situations. We know how to challenge Limitation of Liability claims and build strong cases that hold negligent parties accountable, no matter how powerful they are.
If you or a loved one was impacted by the Cuauhtémoc ship crash, you may be entitled to compensation. Don’t let an outdated law stand between you and justice. Contact us today to discuss your rights, we’re here to help.