The minivan driver suffered injuries to his neck and lower back. Physical therapy failed to relieve his pain, and so he planned to undergo back surgery. After hiring Vuk Vujasinovic, he filed a lawsuit against the truck driver and his company, Cowboy Transportation, demanding compensation for his injuries and punitive damages because the driver was intoxicated.
The defense team claimed that the defendant had been misidentified as the hit-and-run driver and that the driver had not actually been intoxicated. They asked the judge to suppress the evidence relevant to alcohol use, but the motion was denied.
The trial was divided into two parts: the first phase would decide liability and actual damages, and the second phase would set punitive damages, if any. In phase one, the jury found that the defendant had been grossly negligent (thereby opening the door to awarding punitive damages) and awarded actual damages of $112,109. After an additional half-day of deliberations for phase two, the jury added $550,000 in punitive damages, bringing the total verdict to $662,109.